Ethics of Eating Meat

Do you know ethics of eating meat?

Since the last few decades, the question of the morality of slaughtering animals for human needs has remained an essential part of the Animal Rights Movement.

However, the application of inhuman scientific, psychological, and physical conditions on any species is neither ethically righteous not morally acceptable. This discussion is about Peter Singer’s argument about eating meat is morally right or not.

It will explore the objection of Michael Pollan to the initial discussion given by Singer. In the end, the response about criticism by Pollan will be presented by the Singer point of view.

Eating meat is moral, natural, and appropriate in a system where animals are raised in a natural environment, treated well and slaughtered in a proper manner without causing them preventable sufferings. Thus, ethics of eating meat exists.

This argument is sound, elaborates about ethics of eating meat but it is not essential that everyone will be agreed to it.

 Initial Argument:                                                                  

The scholarly community has been debating the question of the morality of eating meat since last few decades. A famous American author and activist Michael Pollan has advanced the debate in a very influential manner.

Being a patron of the Animal Rights Movement, he contends against the unnecessary sufferings of animals that are caused by human experiments.

However, he believes that consuming the meat of animals that are raised in well-cared farms is fine. He believes in animal rights, but he does not consider animals to have an equal quantity of reasons as of humans.

He argues that it is not logical to compare a monkey with a human. By providing an example of the Christmas celebrations, a situation, when on the one hand; some pets receive gifts and love, others smarter animals such as pigs are sacrificed for the family dinner of Christmas celebrations. He questions the amount of equality that could be given to animals when compared with human beings.

Objection:

The father of modern Animal Rights Movement “Peter Singer” raises rational objections on claims made by Michael Pollan. He argues that it is not essential to know that animals cannot speak or reason, but it is, in fact, necessary to know that they can feel.

Although not having an intellectual comparison with humans, animals possess an equal sense of pain. Therefore, there sufferings and interests should be considered equally. He takes practical examples of animal maltreatment by human beings and asks for the equal rights of animals and humans.

The large part of his disapproval arguments revolves around the mistreatment of animals and hypocrisy of social behaviors when it comes to animals.

He argues that the ethics of eating meat on moral grounds in indefensible and the only realistic approach that humans can adapt to decrease the animal sufferings is to halt eating meat products.

The central claims that he makes are following:

1) Animals’ nature should be respected and they must be given rights according to their life

2) Principle of equality extends to all sentient beings of the earth

3) The human and animal interests of “not to suffer” are identical

4) The experimentation on animals is not justifiable.

He says that animals should be brought in the moral concerns of humans and their harmful treatment, for what so ever trivial human purposes should be stopped and banned. 

On page 251 of ‘The Ethics of What We Eat,’ he objects that “each animal kill other animal and animals eat other animals in the natural order, but there are choices for humans.” Humans can survive without eating meat.

Response to the Objection (Ethics of Eating Meat)

Michael Pollan counters the objections raised by Peter Singer, as “how can we treat animals more ethically than their own treatment with one another”.

He gives an example of his domesticated cat and says that she sometimes kills other smaller species for mere pleasure, he argues that humans have intense engagement with the natural world. He admits that animal maltreatment is a legit problem, but he argues that animals are not moral beings.

As Immanuel Kant puts it that “only moral animals are “humans” and the concept of righteous deeds is also entertained by them.” He questions what would be acceptable and virtuous to experiment a new medicine on a human child instead of a monkey.

The human sufferings are different due to the attachment of consciousness and human emotions and can extend from pain to various emotional traumas such as regret, loss, shame, dread, and humiliation.

Bottom line

The Pollen’s response to the objections raised by Peter does make sense. It would be an absolutist stance to believe that eating meat is unethical and immoral in a natural order of life.

Human beings should show mercy on animals and let them live in a natural environment. Animal sufferings should be considered but to a rational extent. In the contemporary era, the fast-food industry is flourishing, and people prefer to eat such food which encourages the practices of forced- mating, fast-breeding, and merciless slaughtering.

Ethics of eating meat is a controversial argument. These practices are disturbing the natural order and life cycle of all species, including humans who are developing many diseases.

Cutting the meat from human diet is also unnatural. Hence, the point is clear that taking a balanced diet, which often includes the meat of farm-raised animals, is right and ethical. Ethics of eating meat works well in civilized societies.

272 Comments

  1. Chet November 23, 2020
  2. Myles November 24, 2020
  3. Waylon November 27, 2020
  4. bitcoin kaufen ablauf November 27, 2020
  5. หวยเด็ด November 30, 2020
  6. หวย November 30, 2020
  7. หวยเด็ด November 30, 2020
  8. หวย December 1, 2020
  9. Mickey December 2, 2020
  10. Erik December 2, 2020
  11. Duane December 2, 2020
  12. หวย December 2, 2020
  13. Fredericka December 3, 2020
  14. Linnie December 3, 2020
  15. Minda December 3, 2020
  16. Clara December 3, 2020
  17. Sabina December 6, 2020
  18. huaydee.com December 7, 2020
  19. Sherman December 7, 2020
  20. Karma December 7, 2020
  21. Jonathan December 8, 2020
  22. Florentina December 9, 2020
  23. Alfredo December 10, 2020
  24. Ernest December 12, 2020
  25. Daniela December 21, 2020
  26. Seymour Melchior December 22, 2020
  27. Deb Awada December 22, 2020
  28. Minda Arndorfer December 22, 2020
  29. Elmo Morguson December 22, 2020
  30. Karren Scalisi December 22, 2020
  31. Roman December 22, 2020
  32. Seth December 23, 2020
  33. indoxxi layarkaca21 December 24, 2020
  34. layarkaca21 lk21 December 24, 2020
  35. Dewey December 24, 2020
  36. Walker Sutor December 24, 2020
  37. Britt Birchard December 24, 2020
  38. Freeman Russello December 24, 2020
  39. layarkaca21 indoxx1 December 24, 2020
  40. Azzie Lecea December 24, 2020
  41. Karen December 24, 2020
  42. layarkaca21 semi December 25, 2020
  43. Marko December 25, 2020
  44. Siobhan December 25, 2020
  45. Janessa December 25, 2020
  46. layarkaca21 December 26, 2020
  47. layarkaca21 December 26, 2020
  48. Fawn December 26, 2020
  49. Santiago December 27, 2020
  50. Cordia Lauderback December 27, 2020
  51. Walker December 28, 2020
  52. Helena Tarrant December 28, 2020
  53. Rita December 29, 2020
  54. avon cosmetics uk January 3, 2021
  55. avon sign up online January 3, 2021
  56. avon representative uk January 3, 2021
  57. join avon online January 3, 2021
  58. find an avon rep near me uk January 3, 2021
  59. how do i sign up for avon January 3, 2021
  60. join avon now January 3, 2021
  61. Avon Joining Fee January 3, 2021
  62. avon rep in my area uk January 3, 2021
  63. find an avon rep near me January 3, 2021
  64. avon cosmetics sales leader January 3, 2021
  65. avon rep near me uk January 3, 2021
  66. become a avon rep uk January 3, 2021
  67. avon cosmetics ltd January 3, 2021
  68. avon Cosmetics January 3, 2021
  69. bắc kinh January 3, 2021
  70. new york university January 4, 2021
  71. diabetes care January 4, 2021
  72. long beaded necklace January 4, 2021
  73. gas oven repair January 4, 2021
  74. facial January 4, 2021
  75. Abcya 2 January 4, 2021
  76. bricks panels January 4, 2021
  77. vreyrolinomit January 4, 2021
  78. tour Lệ Giang giá rẻ January 8, 2021
  79. tour trung quốc January 8, 2021
  80. frolep rotrem January 9, 2021
  81. Hue Perilloux January 10, 2021
  82. Kate January 11, 2021
  83. Jenell Kinlaw January 12, 2021
  84. Reiko Manker January 13, 2021
  85. Magnolia Kromka January 13, 2021
  86. Dan Sago January 13, 2021
  87. Pingback: essay January 14, 2021
  88. Mitzi January 15, 2021
  89. Heidi January 16, 2021
  90. Ervin Seabold January 18, 2021
  91. Loyd Dolfay January 18, 2021
  92. Pingback: cialis with dapoxetine overnight to January 19, 2021
  93. Pingback: cialis in melbourne australia January 19, 2021
  94. Pingback: viragecialis January 20, 2021
  95. Pingback: cialis generic online January 22, 2021
  96. Pingback: next day delivery viagra January 27, 2021
  97. Pingback: cialis using paypal in australia January 28, 2021
  98. cheap flights January 29, 2021
  99. car parts ranging January 30, 2021
  100. cheap flights January 30, 2021
  101. lkq sarasota February 1, 2021
  102. cheap flights February 1, 2021
  103. Archie Kalberer February 1, 2021
  104. cheap flights February 1, 2021
  105. tinyurl.com February 2, 2021
  106. cheap flights February 2, 2021
  107. arlingtons springfield il February 3, 2021
  108. tinyurl.com February 3, 2021
  109. zortilo nrel February 7, 2021
  110. Bryan Pajerski February 8, 2021
  111. tinyurl.com February 12, 2021
  112. Pingback: cialis works better than viagra February 14, 2021
  113. instagram takipci satisi February 23, 2021
  114. antalya haber February 25, 2021
  115. instagram takipçi February 25, 2021
  116. web hosting March 10, 2021
  117. Chauncey March 12, 2021
  118. takipçi satın al March 14, 2021
  119. gamefly March 15, 2021
  120. http://j.mp/ March 16, 2021
  121. ps4 games March 18, 2021
  122. tinyurl.com March 18, 2021
  123. http://bit.ly/3r2uZvK March 19, 2021
  124. window cleaning Denver CO March 19, 2021
  125. web hosting March 21, 2021
  126. web hosting March 22, 2021
  127. Pingback: thesis help online March 22, 2021
  128. tinyurl.com March 23, 2021
  129. takipçi al March 24, 2021
  130. vreyrolinomit March 24, 2021
  131. takipçi instagram March 24, 2021
  132. Addiction Center March 25, 2021
  133. Pingback: professional dissertation help March 25, 2021
  134. havadis March 26, 2021
  135. Elwood Wiatrek April 6, 2021
  136. Jeraldine Schuetz April 6, 2021
  137. 0mniartist April 8, 2021
  138. Rico Ziegenfuss April 10, 2021
  139. Erlinda Wescovich April 10, 2021
  140. j.mp April 15, 2021
  141. antalya izolasyon April 16, 2021
  142. zimbra hosting April 17, 2021
  143. php Shell indir April 19, 2021
  144. antalya böcek ilaçlama April 20, 2021
  145. Leigh Rav April 20, 2021
  146. takipçi satın al April 20, 2021
  147. google April 21, 2021
  148. tabletki na potencję April 21, 2021
  149. Mariel April 22, 2021
  150. Earn monry online April 23, 2021
  151. leke kremi satın al April 23, 2021
  152. Snkrs bot April 23, 2021
  153. en iyi leke kremi April 24, 2021
  154. Ashely Bumpass April 25, 2021
  155. Buy Weed Online Whitby April 25, 2021
  156. commercial acting April 25, 2021
  157. Pingback: monthly cost of cialis without insurance April 25, 2021
  158. halskette männer April 26, 2021
  159. Rocco Worsley April 26, 2021
  160. a gamefly April 28, 2021
  161. Night sky poster April 28, 2021
  162. confinement meal April 28, 2021
  163. asmr their April 29, 2021
  164. mylesalwgq.blognody.com April 29, 2021
  165. asmr was April 29, 2021
  166. subscription April 29, 2021
  167. in asmr April 29, 2021
  168. Takipçi satın al April 29, 2021
  169. Matilda April 29, 2021
  170. takipçi satın al April 29, 2021
  171. Personalisierte socken April 29, 2021
  172. People search April 29, 2021
  173. Rolande Soller April 30, 2021
  174. in house counsel April 30, 2021
  175. böcek ilaçlama April 30, 2021
  176. antalya böcek ilaçlama April 30, 2021
  177. Custom 18650 battery pack April 30, 2021
  178. Wayne Slot May 1, 2021
  179. 레플리카 May 1, 2021
  180. Florentina May 2, 2021
  181. Schmuck für Männer May 2, 2021
  182. Interactive video May 2, 2021
  183. Takipçi Satın AL May 3, 2021
  184. Online shopping bags May 3, 2021
  185. was gamefly May 4, 2021
  186. asmr or May 4, 2021
  187. Verla May 4, 2021
  188. Easy recipes ideas May 4, 2021
  189. Royal Honey VIP May 4, 2021
  190. Logsuz Shell May 4, 2021
  191. Php Shell indir May 4, 2021
  192. Pingback: cialis soft tablet May 5, 2021
  193. Milla May 5, 2021
  194. Sol May 5, 2021
  195. Pingback: monthly cost of without insurance May 5, 2021
  196. Enriqueta May 6, 2021
  197. wso shell May 6, 2021
  198. http://j.mp/ May 7, 2021
  199. Adriene May 7, 2021
  200. Pingback: faxless cash advance hialeah May 8, 2021
  201. Women's heated jacket May 8, 2021
  202. Chanel May 8, 2021
  203. asmr in May 9, 2021
  204. Caitlin May 9, 2021
  205. Southampton escorts May 10, 2021
  206. Pingback: retin a cream no prescription needed May 11, 2021
  207. deep shoulder pain May 11, 2021
  208. 강남사라있네 May 11, 2021
  209. buying eyelashes May 12, 2021

Add Comment